 |
| Photo credit: Jun Lira |
By
Eugenio Lira, Jr.
SURIGAO CITY— First
District Representative Francisco Matugas recently asked the Commission on
Election (Comelec) to dismiss the Petition for Disqualification filed against
him by a rival candidate for lack of cause of action and/or failure to state a
cause of action, and for utter lack of merit.
The petition, which was
filed by Gertrudes C. Saberon on February 22, 2013, specifically alleged that
Matugas “is not qualified to be a candidate for Congressman because he has
committed the heinous crime of PLUNDER defined and punishable under Republic
Act No. 7080.”
Saberon used as evidence
in her petition the September 13, 2012 decision of the Commission On Audit EN
BANC which disallowed the use of Matugas’ PDAF as intelligence fund.
In an eight-page Answer
with Prayer for Summary Dismissal, the lawmaker, through his lawyer Romulo
Macalintal, told the poll body that Saberon’s allegation particularly paragraph
4, together with its sub-paragraphs: 1, 2, 3, 3-A, 4, 5, 6, and 7 were “false
and misleading conclusion of fact and of law, the truth of the matter being
that respondent did not commit plunder.”
“The facts, as alleged
by petitioner, do not constitute any ground to disqualify respondent.
Essentially, petitioner seeks to disqualify respondent on the ground that he
allegedly committed plunder, as defined and penalized under R.A. 7080,”
Macalintal observed.
“Respondent had never
been found guilty of plunder by any court or tribunal. Likewise, he never
committed, nor has he been adjudged guilty of committing any of the acts
enumerated under the above-cited Section 68 of the Omnibus Election Code,” Macalintal
said in his pleading.
He said the Decision
dated September 13, 2012 of the Commission On Audit EN BANC relied upon by
petitioner Saberon as basis for respondent Matugas’ disqualification did not
even relate to any plunder case against the latter for the same merely
discussed the disallowance of the lawmaker’s alleged allocation of his Priority
Development Assistance Fund (PDAF) for intelligence and anti-insurgency
purposes. It did not also propose to make any finding as to respondent’s
alleged liability for the commission of plunder.
“This is plainly logical
since the COA does not have any jurisdiction to make such finding/ruling,” said
Macalintal, adding that “respondent is, thus, puzzled on how said COA Decision
serves as basis for his alleged commission of plunder.”
Considered as one of the
country’s brilliant lawyers, Macalintal further said the disqualification case
was prematurely filed and, therefore, dismissible for lack of cause of action.
“To disqualify a
candidate for the commission of a crime, the law requires prior conviction by
final judgment of a competent court or tribunal. Such requirement is lacking in
this case as respondent has not been convicted of plunder. This is consistent
with the constitutional presumption of innocence, which is guaranteed to every
person accused of a crime,” Macalintal argued.
He cited the case of
Romeo Jalosjos “who was allowed to run for, and serve as, Congressman despite
the pendency of the rape case against him, and notwithstanding, the fact that
he was under detention.”
“Thus, until and unless,
respondent had been convicted by final judgment for committing the crime of
plunder, he should be allowed to run for the position of Member of the House of
Representatives for the 1st District of Surigao del Norte in the
upcoming 13 May 2013 elections,” he argued.
In the said pleading,
Macalintal questioned the truthfulness of the verification of Saberon’s
Petition saying the same was defective as it was executed in Quezon
City and notarized by a notary public whose notarial commission was
only limited to the City of Manila
He also raised serious
doubt as it appeared the Petition was executed and signed on “22 February 2013”
at “Dapa, Siargao, Surigao del Norte” and the jurat of the said verification
indicated the petitioner as male, as evidenced by the use of the word “his” to
refer to petitioner/affiant.
A conference on the said
case is scheduled on April 10, 2013 at 2:00 p.m. at the Comelec Central Office
in Manila
No comments:
Post a Comment